his assignment is divided into 2 parts:
Part 1: Compare the AGC Document No. 200 Standard Form of Agreement and General Conditions Between Owner and Contractor (AGC_200.pdf Preview the document ) and AGC Document No. 415 Standard Form of Design-Build Agreement and General Conditions Between Owner and Design-Builder (Lump Sum) (AGC_415.pdf Preview the document ). What are the major differences between the two forms (at least 5 differences with detailed explanation on how they would impact the contracting parties liabilities and responsibilities)? Be specific by numbering each difference and referencing the contract clause no. pertinent to both contract types.
Part 2: Peer-review 2 of your colleagues work and provide comments – due date one week from submission date (5 points). You are expected to provide constructive comments tackling 2 main aspects:
What is one thing you learnt from reading your peer’s submittal OR one thing you always do that he/she did that strengthens his/her submittal?
What is one thing that you would advice him/her to do to strengthen his/her submission?
Case Study Analysis Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts
Completeness
Complete in all respects; reflects all requirements
5 pts
Complete in most respects; reflects most requirements
3.5 pts
Incomplete in many respects; reflects few requirements
2.5 pts
Incomplete in most respects; does not reflect requirements
5 pts
Understanding
Demonstrates a sophisticated understanding of the topic(s) and issue(s)
5 pts
Demonstrates an accomplished understanding of the topic(s) and issue(s)
3.5 pts
Demonstrates an acceptable understanding of the topic(s) and issue(s)
2.5 pts
Demonstrates an inadequate understanding of the topic(s) and issue(s)
5 pts
Evaluation and recommendations
Supports opinions with strong arguments and evidence (contract terms); presents a balanced and critical view; interpretation is both reasonable and objective
5 pts
Supports opinions with reasons and evidence (contract terms); presents a fairly balanced view; interpretation is both reasonable and objective
3.5 pts
Supports opinions with limited reasons and evidence; presents a somewhat one? sided argument
2.5 pts
Supports opinions with few reasons and little evidence; argument is one?sided and not objective
5 pts
Description of criterion
Presents an insightful and thorough analysis of all issues identified
5 pts
Presents a thorough analysis of most issues identified
3.5 pts
Presents a superficial analysis of some of the issues identified
2.5 pts
Presents an incomplete analysis of the issues identified
5 pts
Total Points: 20